‘Wicked’: DEFRA boss on GM opponents in developing countries

By Michael Stones

- Last updated on GMT

Related tags Gm crops Agriculture Genetically modified food Gm

Opponents of GM golden rice were 'wicked' said DEFRA boss Owen Paterson
Opponents of GM golden rice were 'wicked' said DEFRA boss Owen Paterson
Those who oppose genetically modified (GM) rice enhanced with vitamin A in Africa and Asia are “wicked” and could be responsible for millions of premature deaths, warns environment secretary Owen Paterson.

Paterson slammed environmental groups that are fighting the development of vitamin-rich ‘golden rice’ and supported a letter from a group of international scientists calling for its speedy introduction.

The GM rice could help to prevent deaths of about 670,000 children who die from vitamin A deficiency every year and stop blindness in a further 350,000 children, scientists argue.

“It’s just disgusting that little children are allowed to go blind and die because of a hang-up by a small number of people about this technology,”​ Paterson said in an interview published in the Independent ​newspaper. “I feel really strongly about it. I think what they do is absolutely wicked.”

Without naming individual groups, Paterson said those who opposed GM technology were “casting a dark shadow over attempts to feed the world”.

'Casting a dark shadow'

Paterson said there was no scientific basis for opposition to GM crops. “There are 17M farmers, farming 170M hectares,”​ he said. That represented 12% of the world’s arable area, seven times the surface area of the UK and “no one has ever brought me a single case of a health problem”,​ he added.

Environmental pressure groups such as Friends of the Earth, Greenpeace and GM Freeze have long opposed the introduction of GM crops and animals.

Craig Bennett, Friends of the Earth director of policy and campaigns, said: “What could be termed as wicked is a minister who turns a blind eye to evidence of the very real threat of climate change on food security and the world’s children, and instead puts his faith in unproven silver bullet measures.”

Bennett said his organisation was not campaigning on golden rice. “We are putting our effort into campaigning for tried and tested measures that have been shown to deliver real solutions for farmers and nutrition – such as boosting yields by protecting soils, better water management and affordable access to seeds.”

Threats to food security

Some of the greatest threats to food security include climate change, soil degradation, and a lack of agricultural diversity, he said. “It is highly doubtful that more intensive forms of agriculture such as GM crops will deliver on these issues for farmers or food supply.”

No one from Greenpeace was available to speak to FoodManufacture.co.uk.

Meanwhile, Paterson also used the interview to back an open letter signed by a group of international scientists calling for the rapid introduction of vitamin-A enhanced rice to prevent child deaths and blindness.

The letter published in the American journal Science​ stated: “If ever there was a clear-cut case for outrage, it is the concerted campaign by Greenpeace and other non governmental organisations, as well as individuals, against golden rice.”

Signatories to the letter included 11 leading academics, including two Nobel laureates and the president emeritus of the US National Academy of Sciences.

A spokeswoman for the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) stressed that Paterson’s comments reflected his own views – not those of the government.

Paterson had long been an outspoken advocate of GM science. In January he told delegates at the Oxford Farming Conference that retailers should play a bigger role​ in winning consumer support for the science.

In June, David Willetts, UK universities and science minister, told the Cheltenham Science Festival that Europe risked becoming “a museum of 20th​ century technology”​ unless EU ministers relaxed rules on the development of GM crops. 

Related news

Related products

show more

Discover Noochy Crisp® for health bars

Discover Noochy Crisp® for health bars

Content provided by Gnosis by Lesaffre USA | 23-May-2023 | Product Brochure

In the comfort food market, bars have a major place. Consumers are looking for healthier snacks and are more conscious of functional ingredients in their...

Immune support for everyone

Immune support for everyone

Content provided by Kerry | 16-May-2023 | Infographic

Consumers of all ages cite immune health as a top benefit driving their purchases, along with improving gut/digestive health.

Sustainable Farming in Challenging Times

Sustainable Farming in Challenging Times

Content provided by Südzucker AG | 16-May-2023 | White Paper

Today, farmers are facing many different challenges: Reduction of plant protection options, changing climate conditions and increased production cost,...

H&F Pectin: Plant-based alternative to gelatine

H&F Pectin: Plant-based alternative to gelatine

Content provided by H&F – Innovative Solutions for your Product Developments | 12-May-2023 | Application Note

H&F Pectins are excellent as a plant-based alternative to gelatine in many applications.

Related suppliers

1 comment

Methinks thou doth protest too much...

Posted by Jennifer Christiano,

So, those who oppose the wholesale turnover of the earth's evolutionary processes to a handful of unaccountable corporate interests, government bureaucrats, and their shills in academia, are "wicked"? Is Mr. Paterson a character from The Wizard of Oz??!?
Let's take a vvveeeerrrry close look at the money trails, and see who's buttering Mr. Paterson's bleached, bromated and hybridized white bread. One we see which players in the GE debate are financially and politically in bed with which other players, then the truth about the real costs and assumed benefits of GM foods might become a bit more apparent.
Oh, and, Mr. Paterson, stop hiding behind sick children to push your agenda of financial domination of the global food supply. Your tactic is despicable.

Report abuse

Follow us


View more