‘Bust the myth’ of physical inactivity and obesity, urge researchers


- Last updated on GMT

Exercise may have a role in weight loss maintenance - but it is unlikely to beat obesity without dietary changes
Exercise may have a role in weight loss maintenance - but it is unlikely to beat obesity without dietary changes

Related tags Nutrition Obesity

Public health messages intended to tackle obesity should focus on unhealthy eating rather than physical activity, which does not promote weight loss, according to an editorial published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine.

The ‘calories in versus calories out’ message often is used by the food industry as a formula for weight management – particularly by those companies that sell high-calorie foods and drinks.  ​But the authors of this latest paper say physical activity does not promote weight loss – although it has other health benefits, including reducing risk of heart disease, type 2 diabetes, dementia and some cancers.

“Members of the public are drowned by an unhelpful message about maintaining a ‘healthy weight’ through calorie counting, and many still wrongly believe that obesity is entirely due to lack of exercise,”​ they wrote.

Corporate sports sponsorship

The authors, who include UK cardiologist Dr Aseem Malhotra, argue that carbohydrates – and sugar in particular – promote fat storage. They urge an end to food and drink company sponsorship of sports, citing Coca-Cola as an example, which may suggest that consumption of their high-sugar products is fine if balanced with exercise.

“It is time to wind back the harms caused by the junk food industry’s Public Relations machinery. Let us bust the myth of physical inactivity and obesity. You cannot outrun a bad diet,”​ they wrote.

Exercise for weight maintenance, not loss

Professor Iain Broom, director of Robert Gordon University’s Centre for Obesity Research and Epidemiology in Aberdeen, said the article contained some misconceptions about the effects of different macronutrients but agreed that increased exercise does not contribute to weight loss.

“What exercise (increased activity) does, in association with appropriate dietary intervention, is to promote weight loss maintenance once weight has been lost, but it is a poor contributory factor to promoting weight loss,”​ he said.

Susan Jebb, professor of diet and population health at the University of Oxford, agreed that exercise alone was less effective than dietary interventions to reverse obesity.

“Given that obesity, an unhealthy diet and physical inactivity are all risk factors for chronic disease, it makes good sense to seek to change both diet and activity behaviours to lose weight and improve health,”​ she said.

“To achieve this will need a raft of changes at all levels: practical support for individuals to change their behaviour, changes in local environments to both support better food choices and greater physical activity; and some national policy action too…Rather than trade one off against the other – sugar vs fat, diet vs activity, individual vs population we need to take action across the full range.”

Also responding to the article, Which? executive director, Richard Lloyd, urged the food industry to reduce sugar levels in foods, as well as salt and fat.

“The industry needs to take greater responsibility when promoting products that are high in sugar,” ​he added.


Source: British Journal of Sports Medicine


“It is time to bust the myth of physical inactivity and obesity: you cannot outrun a bad diet”

Authors: A Malhotra, T Noakes, S Phinney

Related news

Show more

Related products

Sustainable Farming in Challenging Times

Sustainable Farming in Challenging Times

Content provided by Südzucker AG | 16-May-2023 | White Paper

Today, farmers are facing many different challenges: Reduction of plant protection options, changing climate conditions and increased production cost,...

The benefits of acacia gum on gut health

The benefits of acacia gum on gut health

Content provided by Alland & Robert | 08-Mar-2022 | White Paper

Consumers are looking for ingredients helping them living a healthy life, and are more and more aware that digestive health is key to global health.

Related suppliers

1 comment

Absurdly Simplistic

Posted by Anthony De Rubeis,

The relationship between taking in calories and burning them is no longer science. The REASON obesity has increased by a factor over the last thirty years DESPITE the plethora of low-cal, no-cal, no-fat, no sugar, no carb foods is directly proportional to the diminishing amount of exercise we are getting. Since the intrusion of the computer and their related games, people, especially children are less and less active as they once were. Calories not burned are stored-period. Their continued diatribe against "the junk food industry" is noted but is not the issue. People make choices of what to eat and junk food (empty calories) are no longer any secret. I don't care what you eat; if you elect to sit all day, you will continue to store calories and fat AND, gain weight. This article, as with many by 'experts,' is nonsense because it places blame and responsibility on the wrong people.

Report abuse

Follow us


View more