Can simpler ingredients revive plant-based dairy?

TBD
Growth in select plant-based dairy segments suggests shoppers are responding to products with clear value propositions and everyday relevance. (Image: Getty/MurzikNata)

The category faces headwinds as consumers seek products with simpler ingredients and strong nutrition and functional claims

Plant-based dairy sales are under pressure, but growth in some segments suggests ingredient simplicity, stronger benefit claims and clearer product usage could help revive declining categories.

Total milk sales, including plant-based milk, reached roughly $22 billion, a 2.7% increase from last year, according to exclusive NielsenIQ data during 52-weeks ending Oct. 6, 2026. Plant-based milk faced a 1.8% fall in sales, alongside a total sales decline for the plant-based category. The only exception is plant-based yogurt and frozen novelties.

Plant-based yogurt and frozen novelties grew sales by 19.7% and 6.1%, respectively, according to NielsenIQ. Both segments are growing because they avoid the biggest headwinds facing plant-based milk: consumer concerns around long ingredient list and increasing demand for naturally protein-rich foods, according to Chris Costagli, VP of Food Thought Leadership at NielsenIQ.

For example, Costagli compares the ingredient quantity between dairy milk and plant-based milk. A majority (81%) of plant-based milk products sold contain 11 or more ingredients, whereas 88% of dairy milk have less than five.

Plant-based reimagined: Reformulating for taste, texture, nutrition and cost

This story is part of a special collection exploring the challenges and opportunities shaping the plant-based food and beverage industry, and how companies are rethinking ingredients, formulations and innovation to deliver on consumer expectations for taste, texture, nutrition and affordability.

Check out the other stories.

Social media searches highlight consumer interest in emerging ingredients

Explore related questions

Interest in the plant-based milk category is up 99.4%, with nearly three quarters of the buzz happening on TikTok, according to Spate’s Popularity Index - Google, TikTok, Instagram US - from October 2025 to September 2026 vs. October 2024 to September 2025.

Searches for oat milk and almond milk are down 21.2% and 14%, respectively. While soy milk interest is growing 10.6%. However, emerging milk bases are gaining traction in searches, according to Spate. Chickpea milk and pea milk searches grew 28.7% and 16.9%, respectively.

Searches for vegan cream cheese nearly tripled the growth of the overall vegan cheese at 46.9% and 16.7%, respectively, according to Spate. Dairy-free cottage cheese is also up at 17.6%. In plant-based yogurt, cashew yogurt searches grew 28.7%.

Beyond protein

Protein continues to shape shopper preferences for conventional dairy. More than half (60%) of consumers say they want to include more protein in their daily diet and 45% looking for high-protein foods seek conventional dairy products, according to Nielsen. Yet, the protein gap persists in plant-based dairy. A majority (86%) of plant-based milks deliver less than 10 grams of protein per serving compared to 87% of dairy milk providing 10 to 15 grams.

“As shoppers put greater emphasis on protein and pay closer attention to what is in their food, alternatives may need to work harder to demonstrate a clear nutritional and functional advantage,” Costagli said.

However, the challenge for plant-based dairy isn’t just adding protein to meet consumers looking for the nutrient. Seventy-eight percent of consumers are looking for protein and additional claims tied to fiber, heart health, lower sugar, gut health and immune support to meet their long-term health goals, according to NIQ.

“For [plant-based] dairy brands, the opportunity is to lead with protein while innovating around the total nutritional profile, ingredient simplicity and benefits that fit consumers’ broader wellness goals. Protein can get a product considered, but the complete nutritional proposition can help determine what gets chosen,” Costagli said.

Reformulation should focus on simplicity

Industry-wide reformulation efforts around reducing or removing sugar and additives without compromising taste or texture pose a challenge for many categories.

For example, plant-based milk brands “should use innovation and reformulation to reduce unnecessary gums, emulsifiers and fillers, prioritize recognizable ingredients, and simplify processing” to communicate the purpose of each ingredient and how it’s made, Costagli advises.

“The opportunity is to make plant-based milk feel less engineered and easier for shoppers to understand and trust,” he added.

“Unsweetened” is a “standout” claim consumers are looking for, according to Spate. Unsweetened almond milk and unsweetened soy milk searches are up 42.6% and 106.9% – both “outpacing their parent categories,” per Spate.

Look at who is winning to build renewed relevance

Brands that are growing in the category can provide insight around “changing priorities like protein, wellness, convenience and value,” Costagli said.

Rather than building a new product or category, brands should rely on marketing strategies to tell a story of how an innovative formulation upgrade gives consumers more reasons to use the product.

“Marketing should help consumers see those products differently by highlighting new benefits, uses and occasions,” he said.

Innovation should build repeat purchases through awareness and trial, including recipes, serving ideas, social content and merchandising.

“Innovation should support that repeat behavior by removing barriers and making products easier, more enjoyable or more versatile to use regularly. The opportunity is to turn initial curiosity into greater frequency, more occasions and lasting consumer habits,” he said.