Can plant-based seafood succeed where plant-based meat stumbled?

The growth of plant-based seafood may depend less on replicating its counterpart and more on the premium positioning, convenience and nutrition that consumers are looking for.
The growth of plant-based seafood may depend less on replicating its counterpart and more on the premium positioning, convenience and nutrition that consumers are looking for. (Image: Getty/SGAPhoto)

Plant-based seafood remains a small fish in the broader plant-based food and beverage pond, but it may have a better path to retail growth than plant-based meat ever did

Although the plant-based seafood category remains relatively small, long-term growth may hinge less on convincing consumers to substitute conventional products and more on creating distinct offerings that deliver value in their own right.

Plant-based meat emerged in the market as a one-to-one replacement for conventional meat where consumers expected an organoleptic replica, explains Julie Emmett, owner and CEO of Emmett Consulting Group. However, plant-based seafood brands can take lessons from both the meat and dairy segments to differentiate themselves through convenience, product variety and premium positioning – and without marketing the products as an alternative.

The broader plant-based category continues to contend with slowing sales. According to the Good Food Institute’s 2026 State of the Industry report, the US plant-based food market generated $7.9 billion in retail sales in 2025. Plant-based meat and seafood accounted for approximately $1 billion of those sales, down 10% from roughly $1.1 billion in 2024, while plant-based milk remained the category’s largest segment at $2.7 billion.

Plant-based reimagined: Reformulating for taste, texture, nutrition and cost

This story is part of a special collection exploring the challenges and opportunities shaping the plant-based food and beverage industry, and how companies are rethinking ingredients, formulations and innovation to deliver on consumer expectations for taste, texture, nutrition and affordability.

Check out the other stories.

Yet given plant-based seafood’s small market share, its growth potential has more in common with plant-based milk than plant-based meat, Emmet said. While plant-based milk grew into a roughly 13% share of the dairy market by directly competing with conventional dairy, plant-based seafood may not need to be a one-for-one substitute for conventional seafood to find success, she added.

Moving beyond foodservice and frozen

Explore related questions

Foodservice has long served as an entry point for emerging alternative protein brands which created opportunities for companies to build awareness and trial before entering into retail. Emmett advises plant-based seafood companies to continue leveraging that strategy while exploring less traditional retail placement opportunities.

Rather than focusing exclusively on the frozen aisle where the category has seen some growth in recent years, brands could test products in grocery service deli departments alongside prepared seafood options, grab-and-go sushi and fresh meal solutions.

Grocery service deli offers a lower-cost and lower-friction opportunity than broader retail expansion, she said.

Emmett suggested brands first establish consumer interest through channels such as social media, direct-to-consumer sales and foodservice before launching targeted retail pilots. Once demand is established, retailers could test products in a limited number of stores, merchandising them near fresh seafood counters or sushi cases and supporting launches with long-term marketing plans.

The strategy, Emmett notes, comes as perimeter sections continue attracting shoppers seeking fresh, prepared and premium food options.

Learning from plant-based meat’s struggles

For Emmett, one of the most important lessons comes from the plant-based meat category’s recent struggles.

“Plant-based meat has struggled to be a one-to-one replacement for conventional meat as there is not a specific need to do so,” she said.

Rather than positioning plant-based seafood products as alternatives to conventional seafood, brands should focus on product quality, taste and texture innovation and nutritional benefits. This strategy also aligns with retailers and manufacturers increasingly moving away from either-or messaging.

“The key is not positioning plant-based seafood or any plant-based items as an ‘alternative,’ which invites comparison and signals sacrifice,” she said.

Price remains a challenge across the food industry, but Emmett noted that consumers continue demonstrating a willingness to pay more for products they perceive as valuable.

“We are seeing a softening in total retail food sales overall,” she said. “But there are many categories, especially around the perimeter, that are still growing.”

Opportunities emerge in convenience-driven formats

Within plant-based seafood, fish alternatives account for roughly 49% of category sales, while prawn and shrimp alternatives have been among the fastest-growing subsegments by volume, according to data cited by Emmett.

The category remains heavily concentrated in frozen, with approximately 70% of retail sales coming from the frozen department, according to Emmett. Frozen provides a practical benefit for brands starting out in retail by reducing spoilage and extending shelf life.

Yet growth is beginning to emerge in formats that align more closely with how consumers eat today. These include shreds, chunks, strips and breaded formats that serve as meal add-ons.