How to avoid food overproduction in an era of shortages

huge piles of apples forming a landscape on their own. No food was wasted during this photosession....well...not much at least.
How can food businesses avoid producing too much? (Image: Getty/OK-Photography)

Creating too much of a product can be costly, especially for food companies


Food overproduction: Overview

  • Overproduction ties up capital, warehouse space and valuable resources
  • Forecasting errors can cause waste, discounting and losses
  • AI and supply-chain visibility improve production planning accuracy
  • Delayed product customisation helps businesses match demand more precisely
  • Inventory buffers reduce shortages but can increase oversupply risks

In food, overproduction should be avoided. It can tie up capital, take up warehouse space and provide food companies with a burden that does not yield a profit.

At a time when food shortages are common, many companies are producing buffer inventories to protect themselves. While this is certainly a necessity, these inventories must be carefully planned in order to avoid overproduction.

Explore related questions

Why overproduction should be avoided

While many companies are, quite rightly, focused on dealing with potential shortages, overproduction comes with its own challenges.

Overproduction ties up capital in labour, ingredients, energy and storage, Lauren Abda, co-founder at investor network Branch Venture Group, points out. Companies risk having to discount or even dispose of products that they can’t sell.

For food, with its perishable products, this can be a particular problem. For perishable foods like meat, dairy and seafood, even small forecasting mistakes can lead to significant losses. However, even when food has a longer shelf-life, it takes up warehouse space and ties up cash.

Food waste. The housekeeper threw away a large amount of expired bread in the refrigerator.
Food overproduction can lead to the necessity for some food to be discounted or even discarded. (Image: Getty/Bombermoon)

Overproduction can even drive down prices, especially when ingredients are interchangeable.

“From an investor’s perspective, reducing overproduction is a win-win. Better production planning means stronger margins, less capital tied up in inventory, and less waste,” says Abda.

For ingredients companies and processors in particular, overproduction can be difficult to avoid, she adds. Such companies must often commit to large production runs months in advance, without knowing how much their customers will need.

Another significant problem with overproduction is waste. “Overproduction can mean valuable ingredients, energy and other resources have been used to make products that ultimately aren’t consumed,” says Jordan Kear-Nash, associate director at consultancy EY.

Finally, while buying large amounts of inventory can reduce cost per unit, Kear-Nash explains, it does not necessarily reduce cost overall. If part of an inventory is written off due to insufficient demand, the cost per unit of what remains rises and the initial cost savings vanish.

Delaying to ascertain demand

In order to mitigate the risk of overproduction, businesses can delay making big decisions until they have a clearer view of demand, says Kear-Nash.

This can be done by keeping products frozen for a longer period of time before defrosting them (although some products cannot be frozen due to impact on quality).

Furthermore, elements of the product’s final composition can be delayed. “Where recipes share a common base, delaying final customisation can give manufacturers greater flexibility over the eventual product mix. But that flexibility has a cost. Additional production stages, handling or storage need to be weighed against the potential reduction in waste.”

These methods do not work for every product, he stresses, but they can reduce the period in which a business is exposed to the potential consequences of a short shelf-life.

If a product really cannot be used, businesses do not need to discard it. It can be utilised as a side-stream, or even as a substitute for a more expensive conventional ingredient.

New forecasting tools can help deal with overproduction

New tools and technologies can help make demand prediction easier. Historically, food supply chains have operated with limited visibility about what was going on both upstream and downstream, according to Abda.

Forecasts and educated guesses were, in many cases, all producers, manufacturers and distributors had.

This is changing, she suggests, with the advent of AI. Along with AI, sensors and better data are helping companies see what’s happening in their supply chains in real time, anticipate demand, and adjust their production accordingly.

Truck loads of discarded tomatoes due to excess production.
It is not always possible to avoid overproduction. (Image: Getty/Andy Sotiriou)

“There’s still a surprising amount of food moving through the system that isn’t digitally tracked,” she says. “As more of the supply chain comes online, companies can make much more precise decisions about what to produce, when, and how much.”

Overproduction is becoming less of an issue due to new technology, Abda suggests. “Overall, I think we’re seeing a shift in the food industry from producing as much as possible to producing as intelligently as possible. Technology is giving companies better visibility and the ability to respond to demand with greater precision.”

This can not only improve profitability and cut costs, but also reduce waste across the food system.

Nevertheless, no forecast can be right every time. Explosive trends on social media platforms such as TikTok can cause demand for a product to skyrocket and subside in a very short space of time, Kear-Nash points out. This is difficult for anyone to predict.

Large-scale food production requires long-term planning, but such trends can come out of nowhere.

Is overproduction a particular problem now?

Shortages in key ingredients are a particular issue at present, with commodities such as cocoa facing severe pressures. This means that food businesses are building large inventories to protect themselves. This can expose them to the potential for overproduction.

“The more protection a business builds against potential shortages, the greater its exposure if demand subsequently falls,” says EY’s Kear-Nash.

Businesses must be able to balance shortage and overproduction risk, he suggests. While they naturally want to protect themselves from shortages, as this can hit not only sales but consumer confidence and brand perception, the risk that a change in demand may cause the brand to “slingshot from shortage into oversupply” is ever-present.

“After years of supply chain disruptions, food companies are understandably focused on avoiding shortages,” says Abda. “But when manufacturers, suppliers, and distributors all build in extra inventory as a precaution, those decisions can add up to significant oversupply.”

Companies should not eliminate these safety buffers, she stresses, but instead be smarter about them. Better forecasting and supply-chain visibility will allow them to make more educated guesses about how much extra inventory they may need, and therefore prevent waste.

In a time of shortages, food businesses must be particularly careful to avoid overproduction. The best thing they can do is plan ahead.