Replicate or reimagine? Non-alcoholic startups choose their lane

As moderation goes mainstream, startups are experimenting with everything from tea-based wine alternatives to electrolyte-infused alcohol-free cocktails.
As moderation goes mainstream, startups are experimenting with everything from tea-based wine alternatives to electrolyte-infused alcohol-free cocktails. (Image: Getty/Frank Legros)

The growing non-alcoholic category is splitting between faithful replicas and entirely new drinking experiences

Innovations within non-alcoholic beverages generally fall into two camps: replication or reinterpretation.

Brands focused on replication continue to rely on grapes and carefully selected varietals, using dealcoholization techniques to create alcohol-free versions that closely resemble conventional wine. Reinterpretation, on the other hand, takes a different approach, using botanicals to deliver wine-like flavors, carbonation to add texture and adaptogens to deliver functional benefits.

The $92.8 billion global low- and no-alcohol beverage category has evolved over the last several decades with brands paying more attention to ingredients, brewing processes and craftsmanship. Those shifts have helped drive the market’s growth, which is projected to reach $167.4 billion by 2033 at a CAGR of 7.8%, according to Data Intelo.

That split between replication and reinterpretation was reflected among several startups during the Summer Fancy Food Show, including Silver Swallow’s tea-based wine alternative and non-alcoholic cocktail maker Dirty Virgo.

Explore related questions

Beta

Silver Swallow emphasizes tea terroirs

Genna Woolston, founder and CEO of Silver Sparrow, created the sparkling non-alcoholic tea-based beverage brand in 2024 when she was looking for options for herself.

Silver Swallow's sparkling tea-based Rosé and Blanc alternative is made from a fermentation process using teas sourced from specific regions like China for more layered flavor profiles, according to Founder Genna Woolston.
Silver Swallow's sparkling tea-based Rosé and Blanc alternative is made from a fermentation process using teas sourced from specific regions like China for more layered flavor profiles, according to Founder Genna Woolston. (Image: D. Ataman)

She noted the gap in flavors between dealcoholized wines, which she says strips away flavor complexity, and other alternatives that were too sweet. In collaboration with her husband, a food scientist, they turned to tea and a fermentation process to create wine flavor profiles devoid of alcohol or added sugar. The teas are sourced from “specific terroirs that have wine-like tasting notes,” like Yunnan, China, Woolston explained.

Silver Swallow offers two flavors, Rosé and Blanc, and contains 4 grams of added sugars per serving.

Alcohol moderation among consumers is expected to grow, Woolston says. While she doesn’t see total abstinence as a market driver, she argues “zebra striping,” which is alternating between an alcoholic beverage and non, is increasingly shaping the category.

“Sometimes you want to drink, sometimes you don’t. But 50% of people are thinking more about when they want to drink and when they don’t. So we’re here for that, either between drinks or altogether,” she said.

The brand launched nationwide via distributor UNFI earlier this year – a relationship she developed through the StartupCPG events. She also credits UNFI’s UpNext program and Startup CPG’s pitch competitions as platforms that helped her secure distributor connections and retail exposure in select retailers across North America.

‘We’re building for the mainstream moderator’

For mocktail brand Dirty Virgo, the focus is on electrolytes in familiar boozy flavors like Margarita, Italian Spritz and Ginger Mule.

The brand’s packaging features ecclesiastical imagery, while its broader visual identity plays on an edgier version of the “virgin cocktail” theme with an image of a tattooed Venus in the famous Birth of Venus painting by Italian artist Sandro Botticelli.

Dirty Virgo's mocktails contain electrolytes as a hydration boost for consumers who are generally switching between alcohol during the night, according to Co-founder John Maloney.
Dirty Virgo's mocktails contain electrolytes as a hydration boost for consumers who are generally switching between alcohol during the night, according to Co-founder John Maloney. (Image: D. Ataman)

The brand’s Co-founder John Maloney cited a gap in the category while working with bars, clubs and music festivals.

“The non-alcoholic cocktail category really started in the fringes of health and wellness, so it’s a lot of functional ingredients, supplement positioning, extreme wellness [and] sobriety lifestyle,” Maloney explained.

While those factors still play a role in the category, Maloney points to the mainstream adoption of alcohol moderation as the driver for Dirty Virgo.

“We’re building for the mainstream moderator, not necessarily the wellness guru, and trying to open this category up to just the everyday social drinker that’s trying to cut back,” he added.

Familiar flavors with a hydration boost

Maloney recognized the demand for more non-alcoholic options in New York City nightlife and created a more familiar flavor profile with Dirty Virgo because “not everybody wants to guess what a black currant aperitif with a proprietary afterglow blend is.”

Maloney said the decision to make electrolytes the brand’s sole functional ingredient was intentional.

First, consumers are more likely to reach for Dirty Virgo after they’ve already had a few drinks, making hydration a meaningful benefit. Second, the co-founders avoided adaptogens and nootropics because those ingredients can interact with alcohol or THC, whereas Dirty Virgo was designed to be consumed alongside either.

Future distribution plans

Dirty Virgo has grown to more than 100 independent accounts in New York, with recent chain authorizations across the East Coast, Maloney said.

The company relied on friends, family and angel investors to raise capital and is now open to a larger pre-seed round as distribution grows.