SUBSCRIBE

Breaking News on Food & Beverage Development - EuropeUS edition | APAC edition

News > Policy

Read more breaking news

 

 

5-c creator Serge Hercberg on nutrition logos, lobbies and conflicts of interest

Niamh Michail

By Niamh Michail+

16-Nov-2016
Last updated on 16-Nov-2016 at 15:16 GMT2016-11-16T15:16:26Z

5-c creator Serge Hercberg on nutrition logos, lobbies and conflicts of interest

France’s ‘five colour’ logo is effective, easily understood and does not discriminate against foods such as cheese or crisps - but the food lobby is determined to block it, says its creator professor Serge Hercberg.

Director of nutrition research at the University of Paris 13, Hercberg led the team of researchers that developed the five colour nutrition logo which, according to academic studies , is the most easily understood by consumers, and the most effective in fuelling health eating choices.

But instead of being adopted by the Ministry of Health, it is currently being trialled in a select number of French supermarkets along with other potential nutrition logos.

Professor Hercberg spoke to FoodNavigator about the influence of lobbies and conflicts of interest in this trial period, and whether he is optimistic that the best choice for public health will be made.

Why is 5c best?

Hercberg explains:

  • It’s simple: The colours run from green to red are intuitive and meaningful for consumers.
  • Unlike the UK’s traffic light logo, which can give one product a green light for sugar and a red light for fat (confusing for consumers), the 5c logo takes into account a product’s global nutrient profile, and includes pink and orange colours.
  • It lets people compare products within the same food type, between food types or between different brands.
  • Studies have shown that it is easily understood by lower socio-economic groups who tend to need clear nutrition advice the most.
  • It does not discriminate whole categories: only 15% of cheeses have a red label, for instance.
  • It will encourage healthy reformulation.

“The food and retail lobbies have pushed the Health Ministry to carry out a so-called ‘life-size’ trial period in supermarkets. From a methodological perspective it’s very complicated. No country has ever done it – not because they don’t want to but because it’s so complex and wastes time.

“Above all, the protocol being used is controversial, there are conflicts of interest and it has led to the resignation of several researchers including the CEO of [France’s national research institute] INSERM who sat on the study’s steering committee. This shows how dubious the methodology is.”

Professor Hercberg added that not enough products have the logo – only around 50% - to give the researchers an accurate idea, with many brands opted out.

“We risk ending up with a study that doesn’t answer any questions. Worse still, it was not given to a team of academics researchers but a structure financed 100% by the food industry. It’s a waste of time and money. It will cost more than two million euros and will produce a very uncertain outcome.”

“Of course, this is just one element of public health policy," he added. "Nutrition problems will not be solved with one logo, but it’s consistent with other tools of information and education.”

To read more about France's trial period and the different nutrition logos that are being tested, click here.

'We will react and respond to any discriminatory measures against Malaysian palm oil,' warns minister

'We will react and respond to any discriminatory measures against Malaysian palm oil,' warns minister

With a recent European resolution calling for tariffs and trade barriers against any palm...

DuPont launches stabilizer for plant-based beverages

DuPont launches stabilizer for plant-based beverages

DuPont Nutrition & Health (DuPont) has launched a new ingredient in its Danisco range...

Seaweed swell: European interest turns tide in superfood’s favour?

Seaweed swell: European interest turns tide in superfood’s favour?

Dr Craig Rose

Managing Director, Seaweed and Co

GEA Aquarius BunchWrapper wrapping machine

GEA sees rise in label-on-stick lollipops

Angelic van der Rijken,

product manager, , GEA Aquarius lollipop equipment,

GEA debuts Comas and Imaforni processing lines

GEA debuts Comas and Imaforni processing lines

Marco Gandini,

VP, head of bakery applications, , GEA

Treofanphthalate-free packaging and mineral oil barriers

Treofan turns to phthalate-free packaging films and mineral oil barriers

Jürgen Schischko

Technical service director, Treofan

Braskem packaging changes color if a product is unfit for consumption

Braskem packaging changes color if a product is unfit for consumption

Marcia Pires

polymer science researcher , Braskem

Manning Impex ups Asian offering for UK market with seaweed snacks

Manning Impex ups Asian offering for UK market with seaweed snacks

UK-based importer and distributor Manning Impex has added Tao Kae Noi seaweed snacks to...

UK cricket flour energy bar wins ife 2017 Sustainable Packaging Award

UK cricket flour energy bar wins ife 2017 Sustainable Packaging Award

Yumpa, a range of energy bars made with cricket flour, is the first of...

Augmented reality: The ultimate hack in flavour perception?

Augmented reality: The ultimate hack in flavour perception?

Dr Katsunori Okajima

Professor, Yokohama National University

Soup-to-Nuts Podcast: Confections hold steady in face of war on sugar

Soup-to-Nuts Podcast: Confections hold steady in face of the war on sugar

Despite significant headwinds generated by the escalating war on sugar and increasing consumer preferences...

UK sugar tax: The big questions

UK sugar tax: The big questions

The UK has announced a tax on sugar-sweetened beverages. But how hard will it...

FiE 2015: Our best bits

FiE 2015: Our best bits

Our teams of journalists were out in force at Food Ingredients Europe (FiE) last...

New tech on EFSA’s horizon: Crowdsourcing and cyber assistants

New tech on EFSA’s horizon: Crowdsourcing and cyber assistants

New technology like crowdsourcing and artificial intelligence computers is the future of risk assessment,...

Lab meat, plant proteins and insects: Which alternative proteins will feed the world?

Lab meat, plant proteins and insects: Which alternative proteins will feed the world?

The quest for alternatives to animal-derived proteins has led to a huge amount of...

Food firms should prepare for pre-recession spending

Prepare for pre-recession spend – top economist

Food manufacturers should prepare for a positive three years ahead, as the changing economy...

Creepy proteins will be hot

New proteins are creeping on trend

Alternative proteins are a “hot area” of interest and products such as sandwich spreads...

Salt reduction not a priority for UK consumers: LoSalt survey

Salt reduction not a priority for UK consumers, finds LoSalt survey

Caroline Klinge

sales and marketing manager, LoSalt

‘Nice wine, no corkscrew?’ Mirabeau En Provence wins 8m+ YouTube views

‘Nice wine, no corkscrew?’ Mirabeau En Provence solution strikes YouTube gold with 8 million+ views

Mirabeau En Provence owner Stephen Cronk says the desire for a direct consumer connection...

DSM claims craft brewer interest in gluten-free beer enzyme

DSM claims craft brewer interest in gluten-free beer enzyme

DSM Food Specialities claims that, far from being cautious, craft brewers are embracing the...

Key Industry Events

 

Access all events listing

Our events, Shows & Conferences...