EU ban on ‘meaty names’ for plant-based products ‘breach fundamental human rights’: Vegan Society

By Katy Askew contact

- Last updated on GMT

Would a veggie burger by any other name taste as sweet? ©iStock/Sarsmis
Would a veggie burger by any other name taste as sweet? ©iStock/Sarsmis
European proposals to block vegetarian or vegan products from using names traditionally associated with meat-based foods are being challenged on the basis that they would breach the “fundamental human rights” of vegans.

Earlier this month, the European Parliament’s agriculture committee backed a ban on vegetarian and vegan products using terminology traditionally associated with meat on their labelling and product descriptions. The proposal, which will go before the full Parliament after May’s European elections, would include terms such as steak, sausage, escalope and burger.

If the stipulation gains the backing of a majority of MEPs next month, vegan and veggie burgers could become vegetable “discs”​ while meat-free sausages could become veggie “tubes”​.

In a 14-page letter sent to European regulators, the Vegan Society said the ban would contravene European citizens’ right to be informed about how the goods should be consumed, denying people seeking out meat-free options the “benefits offered by EU law on clear labelling​”.

The charity argued the proposed measures do not achieve the required threshold for implementation as the EU rules recognise that “any limitation of fundamental rights must respect the principle of proportionality and meet objectives of general interest”.

The Vegan Society also stressed that the proposal would place “excessive administrative burdens”​ on public entities, including schools, health providers, government departments, police forces and prisons. The letter includes an appendix with over 100 examples of plant-based food descriptors being used in the public and private sectors, suggesting many institutions would be affected.

Dr Jeanette Rowley, vegan rights advocate at The Vegan Society, said the proposal is “not aligned”​ with EU policy on diversity.

“It is not in the public interest and, if implemented, would have a disproportional impact across society by affecting the normal daily functioning of all public and private entities that provide food,”​ she stressed, warning of “administrative chaos”.

“The widespread impact of this unreasonable and costly proposal should not be underestimated,”​ Dr Rowley cautioned.

‘Why use the meat names in the first place?’

Dr Rowley cited European food labelling laws that state “food information should … enable consumers to identify and make appropriate use of food”​ and argued the use of ‘meaty’ names informs the consumer how the plant-based products can be cooked and used.

However, a spokesperson for the British Meat Processors Association (BMPA) insisted that the use of meaty names to describe vegetable-based products could be, in itself, misleading for consumers.

“The point is, it is about accurate labelling,”​ the spokesperson told FoodNavigator. “When you get things in the supermarket like ‘meat-free meatballs’ there is almost a hope that you are going to deceive the public.

“Certain things look as though they are going to deceive. Why use the meat names in the first place?”

‘Desperate’ attempt to restrict marketing

Nevertheless, The Vegan Society dismissed the notion as “an attempt to bolster a depressed agricultural economy”​ and warned the proposals – if pushed through – would “create confusion across the EU”​.

George Gill, CEO at The Vegan Society, hit back at the proposal as a “desperate"​ ploy from the meat lobby to restrict plant-based marketing options in the face of growing demand.

“As consumers are increasingly moving away from eating animals, the demand for vegan products is growing. There’s no denying that meat, dairy and egg industries are feeling threatened by this and desperately trying to restrict the marketing of vegan products,”​ Gill – one of the letter’s signatories – argued.

“These proposals have little to do with consumer protection and instead are motivated by economic concerns of the meat industry. We are calling on EU officials to reject these irrational measures for vegan meat alternatives to be banned from using the qualified conventional terms everyone has been using for decades.”

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Clean and natural solutions for food colouring

Clean and natural solutions for food colouring

Kancor Ingredients Limited | 04-Oct-2019 | Application Note

Consumers are well informed these days and hence there is an overall demand for transparency and simplicity in product labelling. The food colouring industry...

Here's How to Increase Yields and Cut Waste

Here's How to Increase Yields and Cut Waste

HPS Product Recovery Solutions | 26-Aug-2019 | Technical / White Paper

From soft drinks, spirits and juices to sauces, paste and soups, hygienic product recovery (pigging) systems recover up to 99.5% of product from full pipelines....

How to find textural perfection in meat alternatives

How to find textural perfection in meat alternatives

Stable Micro Systems | 25-Mar-2019 | Technical / White Paper

An increase in vegetarian diets has led to a rise in demand for meat alternatives. Replicating the texture of meat is vital to consumer enjoyment, but...

Impact of the new Novel Food process on applicants

Impact of the new Novel Food process on applicants

Pen & Tec Consulting Group | 11-Mar-2019 | Technical / White Paper

A year after its implementation, this technical paper questions whether changes to the novel food regulation have brought about positive improvements to...

Related suppliers

5 comments

Show more

Play on words!

Posted by Linda,

When it all boils down a name is a name...we are allegedly an intelligent species with the ability to differentiate between different things...by reading...by touch...by sight...by smell...come on...what a pallava! And if someone accidentally ate a vegan burger....what's the worst that's gonna happen?...I read my labels...I won't get confused. Deary me.

Report abuse

Petrol car

Posted by Stephen,

An electric car is made completely different to a car running on petrol. The engine is completely different, the whole "underbelly" is completely different yet it looks from the outside like every other car. Same thing for a burger no

Report abuse

Opportunity for marketing creativity

Posted by FlotSam,

Since vegan food is avoiding animal food, for lots of justifiable reasons, it seems a pity that there is no attempt at creating names for those wonderful foods. Does the Vegan Society have so little imagination it can only think of discs and tubes as names?
Let's have a clear distinction by names. After all lots of brands and names are being invented. Apple didn't call themselves "A Microsoft Alternative", or "M*crasift" and now everyone knows the brand.
Believe in your own originality and true value, and create your own names please!

Report abuse

Follow us

Featured Events

View more

Products

View more

Webinars