French & German authorities weigh in on 'emotional' glyphosate debate

By Niamh Michail

- Last updated on GMT

"Glyphosate cannot be classed as a probable carcinogen but its use in formulations could be a cause for concern." © iStock
"Glyphosate cannot be classed as a probable carcinogen but its use in formulations could be a cause for concern." © iStock

Related tags Food safety authority European food safety authority France

Glyphosate cannot be classed as a probable carcinogen but its use in formulations could be a cause for concern, says the French food safety authority while the German safety body has called for scientific professionalism to spare consumers unnecessary confusion.

The French opinion says​ that “the available information on the risks of glyphosate alone do not justify, at this stage, its classification as ‘probable carcinogen’”.

However it adds: “The mix of glyphosate with certain co-formulants, notably those in the ‘tallow amine’ family, can present particular risks for users in the general public or the agricultural sector,” ​and has begun an immediate revaluation of such formulations. It has also urged the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) to review glyphosate’s ranking.

On the back of ANSES’ conclusion, France’s ecology minister Ségolène Royal has asked for any herbicides containing glyphosate and tallow amines to be withdrawn from the market.

ANSES was asked to carry out a safety assessment by the French government as well as consumer watchdog group UFC-Que Choisir following diverging opinions issued by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) and the World Health organisation’s International Agency of Research on Cancer (IARC).

EFSA looked at glyphosate alone and concluded glyphosate is unlikely to cause cancer while IARC assessed its use in combination with other chemicals in glyphosate-based formulations, and deemed the chemical to be probably carcinogenic in humans.

According to ANSES, glyphosate is widely used in France both by the professional griculture sector, which used between 5157 tonnes and 7421 tonnes while domestic use accounted for between 1264 and 2055 tonnes from 2008 to 2014.

Confusion reigns in an ‘emotional debate‘

Meanwhile last week the president of Germany‘s food safety authority, the Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR), called for scientific professionalism to spare consumers unnecessary confusion.

BfR had published the results of a study​ it had commissioned into the danger of glyphosate residues in breast milk. It concluded there were no active glyphosate substances in the breast milk samples, although it noted the samples used were unrepresentative of the German population..

"The result shows how important professionally conducted scientific studies are to ensure that consumers are not unnecessarily confused in the emotional debate on pesticide residues"​, said BfR president Dr Andreas Hensel.

"Mothers should not be confused by unfounded claims and should continue to breastfeed as before,"​ said the safety authority.

Its full opinion can be read here. ​ 

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Discover Noochy Crisp® for health bars

Discover Noochy Crisp® for health bars

Content provided by Gnosis by Lesaffre USA | 23-May-2023 | Product Brochure

In the comfort food market, bars have a major place. Consumers are looking for healthier snacks and are more conscious of functional ingredients in their...

Immune support for everyone

Immune support for everyone

Content provided by Kerry | 16-May-2023 | Infographic

Consumers of all ages cite immune health as a top benefit driving their purchases, along with improving gut/digestive health.

H&F Pectin: Plant-based alternative to gelatine

H&F Pectin: Plant-based alternative to gelatine

Content provided by H&F – Innovative Solutions for your Product Developments | 12-May-2023 | Application Note

H&F Pectins are excellent as a plant-based alternative to gelatine in many applications.

Drinking with our eyes first

Drinking with our eyes first

Content provided by Lycored | 28-Apr-2023 | Product Brochure

Whether flavored waters, sports drinks, juices, mocktails or low alcoholic beverages, the beauty behind coloration doesn’t just lie in visual appeal, but...

Related suppliers

Follow us

Products

View more

Webinars