California Almond Board accuses media of skewing its sustainability record

By Niamh Michail

- Last updated on GMT

Is California's almond industry killing off bee populations and drying up the state's precious water resources - or has it been unfairly targetted?
Is California's almond industry killing off bee populations and drying up the state's precious water resources - or has it been unfairly targetted?

Related tags Pollination

Media attention has focussed on the unsustainabilty of California's almond industry, with issues ranging from water overuse during drought and pesticide harm to bees during pollination - but this is unfair says the California Almond Board. 

With 80% of the world’s almond supply coming from California, the sustainability of the industry is an issue of global concern. 

President of the Californian Almond Board, Richard Waycott, told FoodNavigator the particular attention given to almonds was unfair. 

“Almonds don’t use more water than other nuts or stone fruits such as peaches and they use less water than other crops grown here in California such as cotton or alfalfa. 

We’re an industry that is constantly improving on sustainability,” ​he said. 

One kilogram of almonds produced today uses one third less water than 20 years ago, while earlier this year the board invested $2.5m (€2.27m) into third-party research, primarily focussed on improved irrigation and water management.

So why has the almond industry had such a bad rap?

Waycott believes the media has played a significant role in overstating the negative impact of the almond industry. 

“It’s an amazing case study of how some reporters from the media took a story - when the drought came they looked to the second largest crop in California and they focussed on us and didn’t look at others or water usage in total. So we are trying to educate people about the real facts.”

What about the bees?

almond blossom honey bee pollination

Water usage in a drought-ridden county isn’t the only sustainability issue to affect the almond industry. Almond trees must be pollinated by bees and Californian almond growers bring in around 1.6m hives from around the US each year to pollinate their trees, providing a significant source of income for beekeepers.

The fact that bee colonies are collapsing is therefore worrying for the industry. While scientists are not sure about the cause of declining honey bee health, a number of reasons have been suggested including a rise in pests and diseases, a fall in natural pollen sources, a lack of genetic diversity and pesticide use.

Some believe the overuse of pesticides by almond growers is responsible in a big way - last year the Pollinator Stewardship Council claimed 80,000 colonies were poisoned​ as a result.

But the board has invested in research projects with the Honey Bee Health Coalition and Project Apis m., and established a set of Best Management Practices​ which includes information on how to reduce bee poisoning from pesticides - although the guidelines are voluntary.

Waycott even said that bee colonies leave California replenished after the pollination season: “Bees love almond pollen – it strengthens them and the hives through extra nutrition.” 

Peanuts – a more sustainable rival?

But are these efforts enough to ensure supply will meet the rising demand for almonds in coming years?

The crop per tree has been shrinking year-on-year – as has the crop overall, despite expanding acreage which now sits at over one million acres in California alone.

Meanwhile, new product developers may already be looking beyond almonds to find suitable alternatives.

almond milk

This year at IFT, Mintel analyst Stephanie Mattucci predicted peanut milk would emerge as a rival to almond milk due to the ingredient's more eco-friendly credentials – they have a smaller water footprint than almonds and are self-pollinating.

But Waycott urged people to look at the full life cycle of plants and crops in order to have a complete and accurate gauge of sustainability.

Peanuts plants have to be dug up and replanted every year whereas almond trees do not, he said.

Related news

Related products

show more

Download Südzucker’s Consumer Trend Study 2023

Download Südzucker’s Consumer Trend Study 2023

Content provided by Südzucker AG | 14-Aug-2023 | White Paper

For the third time, Südzucker has conducted a research study on consumer needs and purchase drivers in processed foods and drinks, which will be another...

Future Food-Tech London - Download Summit Brochure

Future Food-Tech London - Download Summit Brochure

Content provided by Future Food-Tech London, September 28-29, 2023 | 01-Aug-2023 | Product Brochure

Future Food-Tech's European flagship brings together 800+ leaders from food brands, ingredient providers, pioneering entrepreneurs, and investors,...

Related suppliers

1 comment

Peanut milk, and sustainability?

Posted by Leonadi,

Almond milk as a product is very popular. But if it disappears it would have a noise level impact on the almond industry, or on almond production. If you want to consider sustainability, almonds vs peanuts, lets talk about the amount of carbon seguestered in a million acres of almond trees.

Report abuse

Follow us


View more