Fructose in the firing line: Study warns of weight gain and increased body fat compared to glucose

By Nathan Gray contact

- Last updated on GMT

"Fructose can indeed play a role in weight gain, favor fat deposition, and also contribute to physical inactivity," says senior researcher Professor Justin Rhodes.
"Fructose can indeed play a role in weight gain, favor fat deposition, and also contribute to physical inactivity," says senior researcher Professor Justin Rhodes.

Related tags: Obesity

When compared to the same amount of glucose, consuming fructose could cause ‘significant’ weight gain, physical inactivity, and body fat deposition, say researchers.

The mouse-data findings, published in Nature’s Scientific Reports​, suggest that consumption fructose causes significant weight gain, physical inactivity, and body fat deposition compared to a calorie-matched amount of glucose.

Led by Catarina Rendeiro at the Beckman Institute for Advanced Science and Technology, the team studied two groups of mice for two-and-a-half months: one group was fed a diet in which 18% of the calories came from fructose - mimicking the intake of adolescents in the United States -  and the other was fed 18% from glucose. 

“The present study suggests that fructose per se, in the absence of excess energy intake, increases fat deposition and body wight potentially by reducing physical activity, without impacting hippocampal neurogenesis or cognitive function,”​ concludedRendeiro and her colleagues.

Fructose in the firing line?

The fresh findings come after previous reports suggested that fructose consumption in particular is a ‘key driver’ of type 2 diabetes risk​, and may be more harmful to a number of key health measures​ - including mortality and fertility - than consumption of sugar in the form of sucrose.

These reposts, coupled with data that demonstrates the increasing prevalence of fructose in foods and drinks may be linked with a greater proportion of total caloric intake and increasing obesity, has led to increased focus on the role fructose plays in metabolism.

“Nonetheless, despite the parallel increase in obesity and levels of fructose intake, the specific contribution of this monosaccharide to overweight and obesity in the population remains debatable,”​ said the authors. 

"The reality is that people are not only consuming more fructose through their diets, but also consuming more calories in general,”​ said Rendeiro. "One of the key questions is whether an increase in fructose intake contributes to obesity in the absence of excessive calorie intake.”

Study data

Rendeiro and her colleagues examined the impact of a fructose diet relative to an isocaloric glucose diet in the absence of overfeeding, using a mouse model that mimics fructose intake in the top percentile of the USA population (18% energy).

“The important thing to note is that animals in both experimental groups had the usual intake of calories for a mouse,"​ said Rendeiro. "They were not eating more than they should, and both groups had exactly the same amount of calories deriving from sugar, the only difference was the type of sugar, either fructose or glucose."

Following 77 days of supplementation, changes in body weight (BW), body fat, physical activity, cognitive performance and adult hippocampal neurogenesis were assessed.

Despite the fact that no differences in calorie intake were observed between groups, the fructose animals displayed significantly increased BW, liver mass and fat mass in comparison to the glucose group, the authors reported.

“This was further accompanied by a significant reduction in physical activity in the fructose animals,”​ they said.

"We don't know why animals move less when in the fructose diet," ​commented senior author Professor Justin Rhodes. "However, we estimated that the reduction in physical activity could account for most of the weight gain."

According to Jonathan Min, a study co-author, biochemical factors could also begin to explain how the mice respond to the high fructose diet.

“We know that contrary to glucose, fructose bypasses certain metabolic steps that result in an increase in fat formation, especially in adipose tissue and liver,”​ he said. 

Source: Scientific Reports
Published online ahead of print, doi: 10.1038/srep09589
“Fructose decreases physical activity and increases body fat without affecting hippocampal neurogenesis and learning relative to an isocaloric glucose diet”
Authors: Catarina Rendeiro, et al

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Reduce Sugar. Add Fibre. Use VitaFiber™ IMO

Reduce Sugar. Add Fibre. Use VitaFiber™ IMO

LEHVOSS Nutrition– Gee Lawson | 28-Feb-2019 | Data Sheet

VitaFiber™ IMO is a plant-based food ingredient made from tapioca or pea starches and belongs to the special group of carbohydrates called oligosaccharides....

Chicory root fibre for bread improvement

Chicory root fibre for bread improvement

Cosucra Groupe Warcoing SA | 03-Dec-2018 | Technical / White Paper

Fibruline™ Instant chicory root fibres is an excellent source of fibre for white bread production. It can be used with minimal adaptations of the recipe...

Related suppliers

2 comments

Not real world consumption

Posted by Carolyn Reynaud,

Interesting study, but not necessarily the basis to make recommendations against fructose consumption. It is important to note that not all findings in mouse trials will be mimicked in human trials. Furthermore, the diet followed in the study does not reflect real world consumption of fructose or glucose. You would rarely consume either one independently and you are looking at the very upper level of intake. This article reflects and all-or-nothing approach. This study does not mean that fructose is harmful in moderation as part of nutrient adequate diet. As a registered dietitian and representative of the Calorie Control Council, I feel it is no secret that sugar is best in moderation, but that focusing on diet and activity as a whole is still has more applicable in addressing obesity.

Report abuse

Do not confuse Fructose and HFCS

Posted by CCG,

This article tends to link Fructose with HFCS and glucose with sucrose. However, after digestion, HFCS and sucrose have about the same amount of glucose and fructose in them.

Report abuse

Follow us

Featured Events

View more

Products

View more

Webinars