Momentum builds to overhaul global calorie system

By Rod Addy

- Last updated on GMT

Related tags Energy Us Leatherhead food research

Momentum builds to overhaul global calorie system
A storm in the US over how calories are measured could cross to Europe and an overhaul of the system is long overdue, according to one nutrition expert.

The Almond Board of California is petitioning food authorities in the US to reduce the amount of calories allocated to almonds on food labels. This follows a study​ published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition earlier this month, which claims that almonds should be allocated 20% fewer calories than previously thought.

Similar findings were made after US research into pistachios​ in 2011. The studies challenge the entire edifice of the Atwater general factor system for measuring calories by asserting that aspects such as food structure affect the amount of calories metabolised by the body.  As a result, the absolute calorie content listed on food labels bears little relation to the amount of calories an individual absorbs from the food, experts argue.

Referring to the almond study, Dr Martin Wickham, head of nutrition at Leatherhead Food Research, told FoodNavigator: “A reduction [in calories] of about 20% is groundbreaking and will open the floodgates.”​ He said the subject was now a matter of intense interest to nutrition scientists. He had himself been asked to give presentations about the topic later this year, he added.

Energy locked up in food structure

Although he said not all the Atwater studies were wrong, he continued: “We have known for many years that the so-called energy content of foods as measured by the Atwater tables is incorrect. A lot of energy is locked up in the food structure.

“It’s time to look back at the Atwater general factor system and see how valid it is. We are well overdue [for this].”

Indeed, some aspects of the Atwater general factor system, which was based on research conducted in the early 1900s, solely depended on studies of Wilbur Atwater’s laboratory assistants. It would not bear the scrutiny of modern scientific method, said Wickham.

Pressure from trade groups representing nut producers would eventually cause the issue to be debated for other foods, he said.

Nuts, seeds, vegetables

“Anything with cell walls acts as a barrier to energy absorption."​ In particular, the structure of nuts, seeds and vegetables prevented many of the calories from such foods being metabolised, he added.

However, although he recognised the issue could cross the Atlantic and take hold in Europe, it would be some considerable time before the law on calorie labelling could be overhauled. And to his knowledge there were no signs of commercial interest in doing so within the EU.

EU calorie measurement is based on values for fat, protein and carbon, which were firmly set, said Wickham. The only grey area is fibre, for which values vary and are potentially zero, since fibre is considered to be non-digestible.

An overhaul of the Atwater system would take considerable time, but Wickham said it could be done.

Related news

Related products

H&F Pectin: Plant-based alternative to gelatine

H&F Pectin: Plant-based alternative to gelatine

Content provided by H&F – Innovative Solutions for your Product Developments | 12-May-2023 | Application Note

H&F Pectins are excellent as a plant-based alternative to gelatine in many applications.

Related suppliers


Makes one wonder

Posted by Helen Wessels,

As a dietitian this concerns me a bit regarding the actual bioavailability of micronutrients in the same foodstuffs. To what extent does the food structure then influence micronutrient utilisation? There is a need for separate labels on "nutritionally active" micronutrients in foods vs. the actual measured micronutrients as on our traditionally used tables.

Report abuse

EU Calorie Value for Fibre

Posted by M Bond,

The penultimate paragraph indicates that there is a grey area around the caloric value ascribed to fibres within the EU. This is no longer true. The European Commission has established in Directive 2008/100/EC that "it is appropriate
that the average energy value for fibre should be 8 kJ/g(2 kcal/g)", and from 31 October 2012 this is the value that should be used for all fibres in the EU (irrespective of whether the fibres themselves are recognised as exhibiting higher or lower caloric values).

Report abuse

Follow us


View more