SUBSCRIBE

Breaking News on Food & Beverage Development - EuropeUS edition | Asian edition

News > Science

Read more breaking news

 

 

‘More salt than seawater’ – Study slams UK cheese salt content

3 commentsBy Mark Astley , 29-Nov-2012

‘More salt than seawater’ – Study slams UK cheese salt content

Consensus Action on Salt and Health (CASH) has called on the UK Department of Health to set lower salt content targets for cheese manufacturers, after a study discovered some cheese products contain more salt than crisps or seawater.

The study, which was conducted by CASH, involved the analysis of 772 UK supermarket-available cheese products. CASH discovered that many popular cheese products “were unnecessarily high in salt.”

Cheddar – the country’s favourite cheese – was found to contain an average of 0.52g per 30g portion - more salt than a packet of crisps. Other cheese products were found to contain more salt than seawater.

On the back of the group’s study, CASH chairman Graham MacGregor has urged the government to “stop dragging its heels” and set a new, lower salt content target for cheese manufacturers.

The Department of Health must stop its delaying tactics and set new much lower targets for cheese manufacturers, and make sure they achieve them. The cheese industry must comply if we are to save the maximum number of lives,” said MacGregor.

Industry backlash

The CASH study has, unsurprisingly, been met with opposition from the UK dairy industry.

The UK Dairy Council, which provides science-based information on the role of dairy foods, has criticised CASH for drawing health conclusions from a survey that reveals “a lot of what is already known.”

“The CASH survey is mixing up the effect of cheese on health with the effect of salt on health,” said Dairy Council director, Dr Judith Bryans.

Cheese is a whole food with a complex nutritional make up which has not been shown to cause heart disease or stroke. The National Diet and Nutrition Survey shows that cheese contributes only 4% of the nation’s salt intake.”

Responding to the calls from CASH for government intervention, Bryans added: “Salt is an integral part of the cheese making process.”

“It is not added for taste or flavour but for safety and technical reasons. In actual fact cheese manufacturers have worked very hard to reduce salt levels in their products and worked constructively and positively with government agencies to do this whilst providing products which are nutritious, safe and acceptable to the consumer.”

“We do not think it is constructive to send out a message that a cheese sandwich is not good for you,” she added.

More salt than seawater

Roquefort – a French sheep’s milk blue cheese – was identified as the saltiest cheese in the survey, containing 3.43g of salt per 100g portion.

Cheese Singles, and Cypriot cheese Halloumi followed closely, with 100g portions containing 2.51g and 2.71g of salt respectively.

Salt levels in these cheeses were higher than in seawater.

Meanwhile, salt levels in certain varieties of Mozzarella, Emmental, and Wensleydale were some of the lowest in the survey.

The study also revealed huge variation in salt content between cheese products.

For example, the Co-operative’s Truly Irresistible Piccante Gorgonzola contains nearly 0.98g of salt per 30g portion – six times more than Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference Torta con Gorgonzola, which contained just 0.17g per portion.

3 comments (Comments are now closed)

Salt is for more than taste

The salt level in cheese is one of its primary food-safety mechanisms - inhibiting microbiological growth - which must be considered by any regulatory body that wants to "slash" the salt level in any cheese.

Report abuse

Posted by Foodie
04 December 2012 | 23h00

so what

have you tasted seawater recently? Its not very salty ( all those melting icecaps maybe). No wonder some cheeses taste more salty. CASH need to work more on educating people about balanced diets. Plenty of fruit and veg to balance a moderate intake of delicious cheeses.

Report abuse

Posted by mike j
30 November 2012 | 11h17

salt myths relevance of reference points?

How valuable are the CASH comparators, we evolved from the sea so what is the salt level in sea water (3.5%) and how important is this? the pivotal study DASH sodium trial is flawed as the study group were low in potassium, critical for excreting sodium so emphasising any impact of sodium, and the levels were not equal across the groups.

So what about crisps, as they deliver salt on the surface and our salt receptors are on the surface of the tongue. If we consumed all our calories from crisps, potentially enjoyable but nutritionally questionable, our intake of salt would be below the 6g UK target. They contain half the less than half the level in sea water whatever that means.

So why use sea water or crisps as reference points?

Report abuse

Posted by Mythbuster
29 November 2012 | 17h00

Related products

Live Supplier Webinars

Rethinking Fat Forum
William Reed Business Media

On demand Supplier Webinars

Your future starts at Cargill's T for Trends
Cargill Cocoa & Chocolate
Food testing — let automation take the strain
Qiagen
ETENIA™: Recognize True Milk Value
AVEBE
The FoodNavigator Salt Reduction Forum
William Reed Business Media
All supplier webinars