Breaking News on Food & Beverage Development - EuropeUS edition | Asian edition

Headlines > Legislation

Could the WTO overturn EU health claim laws?

By Shane Starling from Brussels , 22-Apr-2013

Loading...

Aggrieved companies and  trade groups have already mounted legal actions against the EU’s strict health claim laws – they are in process – but the regulation’s workings could face fresh challenge from governments signed up to the World Trade Organization (WTO), according to a Brussels-based legal expert.

Emmanuel Saurat, an associate in the Brussels office of Sidley Austin, told a conference in the EU capital last week that the European Union’s nutrition and health claims regulation (NHCR) was at odds with WTO free trade principles.

According to those principles and agreements, the NHCR may restrict commercial free speech, trade between EU and non-EU countries as well as the use of trade marks.

Speaking to us after his presentation, Saurat spoke of NHCR prohibitions that may provoke actions by the governments that have signed up to the WTO.

“The WTO has a specific agreement on technical barriers to trade and this agreement basically prohibits labelling measures which have a discriminatory impact on imports from third countries.

“The EU health claims regulation is clearly a technical regulation which falls within the scope of that agreement and so with any decision which accepts or rejects an individual  health claim; and that’s why the WTO is relevant to the health claims regulation.”

Speaking of botanicals, for the moment on hold under the NHCR as scientific criteria is debated among EU member states, Saurat highlighted the impact on those countries that are often the raw material providers.

“Decisions on health claims can have a disproportionate impact on these countries…that’s where potentially you might be able to bring claims of discrimination.”

But he affirmed that under the WTO remits, only governments, not individual parties, can mount actions.

159 governments are signatories to the WTO. Its website states the organisation is, “Essentially…a place where member governments try to sort out the trade problems they face with each other.”

‘If kids don’t like it, you won't get far’: Daioni boss on healthy dairy drink success

‘If kids don’t like it, you won't get far’: Daioni boss on healthy dairy drink success

Welsh farmer turned entrepreneur Laurence Harris tells BeverageDaily.com about his nationwide distribution ambition for...

Bakeries struggling with calls to cut salt, sugar and fat

Bakeries struggling with calls to cut salt, sugar and fat

Manufacturers of baked goods are reaching a point where calls to cut salts, fats...

‘Functional beverage belief is back’: Zenith International chair

‘Functional beverage belief is back’: Zenith International chair

Zenith International chairman Richard Hall tells BeverageDaily.com that he thinks the beverage industry is...

Behavioural economist: Do the nutritional thinking for people if you want change

Behavioural economist: Do the nutritional thinking for people if you want change

Consumers don’t really want more nutritional information, they want an easy life, according to...

Simplicity, not science, rules sweetener coverage

Simplicity, not science, rules sweetener coverage

Professor Jason Halford

University of Liverpool

Algatech: Functional food on astaxanthin horizon

Algatech: Functional food on astaxanthin horizon

Israeli firm Algatechnologies will work towards gaining approval for its astaxanthin as a novel...

InHarvest: Legumes, pulses steal spotlight from animal protein

At the 2014 Research Chefs Association Conference & Culinology Expo, FoodNavigator-USA caught up with...

Industry must debunk whey protein bodybuilding myths: Volac

Industry must debunk whey protein bodybuilding myths: Volac

Michael Hiron

Commercial Manager, Lifestyle Nutrition, Volac

Could oats be the next gluten-free star?

Could oats be the next gluten-free star?

Oats, when the supply chain ensures no cross-contamination, are a gluten-free cereal grain. So...

In conversation with the mastermind behind the €250,000 lab-grown burger

In conversation with the mastermind behind the €250,000 lab-grown burger

Last year Professor Mark Post sparked international interest with the unveiling, and tasting, of...

Manufacturers miss big breaks with small innovations

Manufacturers miss big breaks with small innovations

Food and drinks manufacturers could be missing out on ground-breaking new product development opportunities...

Invest in small food firms or risk losing income

Invest in small food firms or risk losing income

Big food and drink manufacturers should invest in small firms to protect their income...

Food Vision 2014: Bridge knowledge gaps, overcome change and work sustainably

Food Vision 2014: Bridge knowledge gaps, overcome change and work sustainably

What is the future of food? Simple communication of complex advances will be crucial,...

Talking Rain CEO: Pepsi and Coke weren’t even looking at sparkling waters

Talking Rain CEO: Pepsi and Coke weren’t even looking at sparkling waters

Talking Rain’s Sparkling Ice brand plugs a market gap that Pepsi and Coca-Cola missed,...

Innovation for today: Digital tech empowers industry to innovate

Chris Cornyn

founder & president, DINE Marketing

Foodex 2014 – video highlights

Foodex 2014 – video highlights

The consequences of the horsemeat crisis, filling the yawning skills gap, lean and green...

Beware due diligence issues post-horsegate – lawyer

Beware due diligence issues post-horsegate – lawyer

Due diligence has weaknesses and isn’t a perfect defence against food fraud, despite offering...

Food firms missing out because of ‘dinosaur attitude’

Food firms missing out because of ‘dinosaur attitude’

A “dinosaur attitude” is causing food and drink manufacturers to miss out on the...

Festive video insights: Mintel experts offer up highlights and predictions

Festive video insights: Mintel experts offer up highlights and predictions

With 2013 fast drawing to a close and 2014 just around the corner, we...

Key Industry Events

 

Access all events listing

Our events, Events from partners...